I have made 2 attempts to submit the survey, but my write up of suggestions takes to long and it kicks me out. so.... going to put this out there:
Pull ideas from other management games:
BAT Racer, but only to a certain point. The failure rate is too high in BAT racer, especially in the sports car series where I spent (notice the past tense) all my time. Very hard to take that you are knocked out in the first 5 laps at LeMans due to a part failure or because someone was too aggressive and took you out.
There should be tiers for the failures...
if a part is over 80%, there should be something like 0.06% chance per part per lap (so 8*.06= 0.5% max)
from 80 to 60 it goes up to 0.18% per part per lap (8*.18=1.5% max)
60 to 40 up to 0.5% per part per lap (8*.5=4.0% max)
below 40 you could make 2 or 3 categories with the last one guaranteeing a part failure before hitting 0%.
Of course parts deteriorate at different rates, and there should be a small random factor in addition to push level acting as a small multiplier, which is why I am rounding. Also if this means only 5 cars in a 32 car field finish, then obvoiusly the percentages need to come down.
Also when a part fails, the replacement "cost" will double (doesn't have to just be a financial doubling) because you assume the car was damaged due to the failure instead of normal wear and tear. Possibly even cause a setback in your devolpment of the failed part for the current and next season because you as the boss fear the engineers have gone down the wrong path.
Finally, if a tire blows the suspension and underbody should start to wear at a minimum rate of 10% per lap (Monaco, with Spa and Japan being more due to their length). May need to convert damage to % per km
I would also like to see that if something does fail on a car, and it is a 2 car team, the other driver has to make an adjustment and maybe he will no longer use the 5/5 push and go all out or if he has low mental stats he gets paranoid and is driving 5sec a lap slower
For the once a week leagues (which I have both my teams in) it will be heartbreaking to fall out like that, but podiums and wins could be that much sweeter.