ios-personmd-notifications md-help-circle

Profile

  • Guest
    medal 0
  • Posts: 21
  • Post Likes: 3765

Notifications

  • No Unread Notifications

Suggested
Tyre Temperature & Wear Model

angle-double-left ios-arrow-back 1 ios-arrow-forward angle-double-right
medal 6398
75 days ago (Last edited by Eduardo L. Faria 7 days ago) Translate
I think the current tyre model could be made considerably more realistic by improving two areas: temperature sensitivity and the relationship between tyre design points and durability/performance.

First, regarding temperature: tyres should naturally heat up in corners and cool down on straights, but the effect could be more dynamic rather than simply switching between heating and cooling. For example, high-speed corners, heavy braking and acceleration should generate more heat, while long straights should gradually reduce tyre temperature. Ambient temperature, track temperature and driving style could also influence how quickly tyres gain or lose temperature.
More importantly, the compounds should be much more sensitive to their operating temperature. Something like:

  • SS: optimal around 5–10°C

  • S: optimal around 11–21°C

  • M: optimal around 22–32°C

  • H: optimal above 32°C


These ranges are just examples, but the important point is that the compounds should have meaningfully different performance curves. If the track is 25°C, for example, the M should clearly outperform the S because it is operating closer to its optimal range. The difference should be large enough that choosing the right compound becomes an important strategic decision rather than a marginal one.
===
The second issue is tyre development.
At the moment, we can have tyres with something like 66 design points versus 180 design points, yet in actual races I often don't see a meaningful difference in degradation. Cars seem to reach approximately 50% tyre condition at very similar laps regardless of how developed the tyre is. If that is effectively the case, there is very little incentive to invest in tyre development.
I would suggest that design points should directly affect both tyre performance and tyre lifespan.
For example, as tyre design improves:

  • Higher design points = slightly faster lap times.

  • Higher design points = slower degradation.

  • Higher design points = a wider or more stable operating window.

  • Higher design points = less performance loss as the tyre ages.


So a tyre with 180 design points should not simply be a tyre with the same degradation curve as a 66-point tyre. It should be capable of maintaining competitive performance for significantly longer.
Ideally, tyre wear should also be represented as a continuous performance curve rather than simply "good until 50%, then bad." A highly developed tyre could maintain 75–100% of its potential for longer, while a poorly developed tyre might begin losing performance much earlier.
This would create a much more interesting relationship between development, qualifying pace, race pace and strategy.
For example:
66-point tyre: faster initial degradation, narrower temperature window, greater lap-time loss with wear.
180-point tyre: better peak performance, slower degradation, wider temperature window, and significantly more competitive late in a stint.
That would make tyre development strategically meaningful. Teams would have a real reason to spend development points on tyres because the investment would translate into faster laps AND longer stints, rather than simply producing a tyre that appears to reach the same 50% wear point as a much less developed tyre.
In short, I think the ideal system would make compound choice, temperature management and tyre development interact with each other. The best tyre would not always be the softest one. It would depend on track temperature, how aggressively the car is driven, the expected stint length and how developed the tyre is.
===
I know this would probably be quite difficult to CODE and balance, but I think a system like this could make the tyre model much more interesting and realistic.
===
Sorry for the wall of text!


md-quotelink
medal 6240
72 days ago Translate
All of the proposed improvements are negated by the current DRS model. Unfortunately, the developers aren't even considering reducing the impact of this system. As a result, there is no variety in strategies, and there never will be.
md-quotelink
medal 6311
72 days ago
I think you brought up a good point. It feels like the temperature doesn't matter as much in w2w as it used to in the 2D race model.
md-quotelink
medal 6398
56 days ago (Last edited by Eduardo L. Faria 42 days ago)
Yesterday in Great Britain, the temperature was 14°C and the best-performing tires turned out to be M and H. Ideally, it should have been SS and S or S and M.
The teams on M and H managed four stints, while those on S had to do five stints and finished 18 seconds behind.
Been There Done That
starstarstarstarstar-half-empty
MTWTFSS 00:30igp-fuel igp-tyre md-stopwatch md-flag igp-car igp-car 1 chronometer 100% md-speedometer 2x
md-trophy7,001
ios-person 22 / 32Active
md-quotelink
medal 7369
56 days ago
Well, It was found that was the case, since the new update changed the tire physics. Back then the H tires in these temps were cold so 5 stints were the best strategy for sure, but now maybe they overdid it in the most recent update 
md-quotelink
medal 6398
42 days ago (Last edited by Eduardo L. Faria 41 days ago)
Again. 
Russia, the temperature was 9°C and the best-performing tires turned out to be S and M. Ideally, it should have been SS and S. 
The teams on S and M managed 3 stints, while those on SS and S had to do 4 stints and finished 15 seconds behind.
Been There Done That
starstarstarstarstar-half-empty
MTWTFSS 00:30igp-fuel igp-tyre md-stopwatch md-flag igp-car igp-car 1 chronometer 100% md-speedometer 2x
md-trophy7,001
ios-person 22 / 32Active
md-quotelink
medal 6398
18 days ago
Austria, the temperature was 5°C and the best-performing Tyre turned out to be M. Ideally, it should have been S. 
(100% - race)

Been There Done That
starstarstarstarstar-half-empty
MTWTFSS 00:30igp-fuel igp-tyre md-stopwatch md-flag igp-car igp-car 1 chronometer 100% md-speedometer 2x
md-trophy7,001
ios-person 22 / 32Active
md-quotelink
medal 7047
17 days ago
Hi. I agree with almost everything you said . My problem is with the tyre working the Best in a specific temperature range. I don't think that's really the think to go on,as Mediums and Hards can perform in cold,the idea is to manage how the tyres heat up to ideal temp,and If you don't get the tyres to optimal temp or You do that in a wrong way you can have the graining which then affects the tyre performance,this can work. But i don't think a specific graph of temps and tyre which works the Best in rha range would be good 
md-quotelink
medal 6398
17 days ago
Bogdan
Hi. I agree with almost everything you said . My problem is with the tyre working the Best in a specific temperature range. I don't think that's really the think to go on,as Mediums and Hards can perform in cold,the idea is to manage how the tyres heat up to ideal temp,and If you don't get the tyres to optimal temp or You do that in a wrong way you can have the graining which then affects the tyre performance,this can work. But i don't think a specific graph of temps and tyre which works the Best in rha range would be good 

The problem with the current system is that it gets boring because most races end up using the same setup, regardless of the temperature. Medium tyres are also dominant in almost 100% races, which reduces the variety of strategies.

For example, yesterday in Austria, the temperature was just 5°C, and I considered doing five stints: 4xS + 1xM, because I expected Softs to be much better than Mediums in such freezing conditions.
However, when I was about to make my first pit stop, the Mediums were already ahead, so I changed my mind and went back to my standard strategy: 1xS + 3xM.
That's exactly what I find frustrating about the current system. Even in extreme temperatures, the same tyre strategy often remains the best option. Temperature should create meaningful strategic choices, not just be another number that has little impact on which compound is actually worth using.

Been There Done That
starstarstarstarstar-half-empty
MTWTFSS 00:30igp-fuel igp-tyre md-stopwatch md-flag igp-car igp-car 1 chronometer 100% md-speedometer 2x
md-trophy7,001
ios-person 22 / 32Active



md-quotelink
medal 7047
17 days ago
A problem in that is also the Drs and the dirty Air. If the Drs trains weren't this powerfull it would be better
md-quotelink
medal 6490
17 days ago
Currently, the best strategy tends to be the one used by the majority of the field: opting for harder tires to stay within the DRS train toward the end of a stint. I agree that the "Tire Economy" attribute should play a more significant role in races and that tire behavior could be better developed; however, as previously mentioned, the issues surrounding "dirty air" and DRS should also play a greater part in enabling alternative strategies.
md-quotelink
medal 6398
7 days ago
Great Britain 
5°C. 
The Soft compound should have shown a clear pace advantage over the Mediums and Hards. Both were not expected to reach an optimal operating temperature and therefore should not have been competitive. Instead, the Mediums and Hards proved to be the best-performing tyres, matching the pace of the Softs. For a 100% race distance and no refueling, the expected performance order should ideally have been Supersofts followed by Softs at 5C temperature.

Based on the current performance, Mediums are by far the strongest tyre at ANY TEMPERATURE. 
The meta strategy is 1 x Soft + N x Mediums or N x Mediums + 1 x Hards when two compounds are mandatory. If there's no mandatory compound rule, then a Medium-only strategy will almost certainly be the fastest and most effective option.

Boring.
Been There Done That
starstarstarstarstar-half-empty
MTWTFSS 00:30igp-fuel igp-tyre md-stopwatch md-flag igp-car igp-car 1 chronometer 100% md-speedometer 2x
md-trophy7,001
ios-person 22 / 32Active


md-quotelink
angle-double-left ios-arrow-back 1 ios-arrow-forward angle-double-right

You must be logged in to post a reply.