ios-personmd-notifications md-help-circle

Profile

  • Guest
    medal 0
  • Posts: 21
  • Post Likes: 3765

Notifications

  • No Unread Notifications

3 Accounts Per Device

Do you agree with this?

21.82% (12)
Yes
78.18% (43)
No
angle-double-left ios-arrow-back 1 2 ios-arrow-forward angle-double-right
medal 7856
5 days ago Translate
Hi Jack, thanks for unblocking my account just now; I’d like to explain my situation to you. Before 2026, I had three accounts because I used them to play in three different leagues. When you rolled out the 2026 update, I paid for VIP, and now I can play in three leagues from this account, which is my main one. I think it’s unfair to ban this account just because it was created on a device where two other accounts were also created, when I’m currently paying money to avoid doing exactly that—playing in more than one league.




md-quotelink
medal 7230
5 days ago Translate
Hey!

I wanted to add my point of view. I completely agree that creating 1000 accounts, 100 even 5 in a single day is unacceptable and should be dealt with. 3 accounts per device is reasonable in theory. However there are many cases were this might be too few. 

For example I was unaware of these players that have entire leagues filled with their own accounts... If they are just managing and roleplaying seasons etc, I don't see the foul play.

Or if a device has created more than 3 accounts over the years, if they are not actively using them to alter the market or tilt the game to their favour, I do not see why they should get their accounts restricted.

If a device has created many accounts over the years, they could be requested to give an explanation and give their word to use them in a fair way. I am sure that many of these multi-accounts do have an innocent origin ( to play with friends on other leagues, other projects etc.) For example I know some friends that created 15+ accounts just to run a 2 week long league last summer with lvl 1 accounts, so everyone had the same "specs", and only 2-3 persons created all accounts because it was easier to organise that way. That's just an example.

md-quotelink
CEO & CTO medal 5414
5 days ago
SERGIO
Hi Jack, thanks for unblocking my account just now; I’d like to explain my situation to you. Before 2026, I had three accounts because I used them to play in three different leagues. When you rolled out the 2026 update, I paid for VIP, and now I can play in three leagues from this account, which is my main one. I think it’s unfair to ban this account just because it was created on a device where two other accounts were also created, when I’m currently paying money to avoid doing exactly that—playing in more than one league.

Indeed, that was not the intended behaviour either. Perhaps naively, we didn't collect data on whether VIP users also have more than 3 accounts before enforcing it. This is all useful to understanding the impact on everyone. Thank you for writing your thoughts patiently, it must have been an unpleasant surprise.

Sorting accounts that are valid by priority will be important before any future attempt.

Bruno
Or if a device has created more than 3 accounts over the years, if they are not actively using them to alter the market or tilt the game to their favour, I do not see why they should get their accounts restricted.

Regarding these cases, it's worth adding that they would not be impacted. Only accounts with 3+ shared on a single device (not even a single IP, a single device) in the last 30 days were included in this first rollout attempt.

Don
You still didn't address my and my brother case here. Or you will just ignore these cases?

Actually, it's been reverted, you can login to all the accounts again, while we review the situation.
md-quotelink
medal 5025
5 days ago
Jack
Actually, it's been reverted, you can login to all the accounts again, while we review the situation.



Thank you and If I can plead the case some more. We just restarted the league (3rd season now) because I had some personal issues. But I let me give you our old spreadsheet so you can see that this is not a farming league, it's not used to cheat or manipulate anything. It's just enjoying the competition. You can check league activity too. All teams are setup with strategies... 

But here is our old league history and rules and stuff. So please consider that lot of work was put into this.

Offline Classics

md-quotelink
medal 6489
5 days ago (Last edited by Slo Bro 5 days ago)
Profesor
There's a new restriction in place. You can try it yourself too, since I know you have more than 40 accounts. You'll see that you won't be able to access them!


I’ve seen that and thanks for pointing that out. Back in the day, for hosts it was the only way to activate promotion and to fill up a league in order to make it visible in league search screen. I haven’t used those accounts since then.

So unless you’re administrator of a super competitive league or a role game immersive league, again, I don’t see a reason to have 4 or more accounts. Unless farming young drivers or other foul play practices 
md-quotelink
medal 6680
4 days ago Translate
For example, I have 7 accounts, all competitive and constantly online. Choosing only 3 out of 7 available is a bit limited. In my opinion, the 3-account limit could be raised. Many long-time managers have 5 or more accounts.
md-quotelink
medal 6189
4 days ago Translate
Another crazy idea. There seems to be no rational plan behind the game's management. Or perhaps there is one, but there's a complete lack of ability to make long-term decisions.
After the last two years of the game, I can honestly say that this is my firm conclusion.
In any case, instead of blaming the person who creates 1,000 accounts, it would have been enough to require each account to be linked to a verified email address and limit each user to a maximum of three accounts.
I don't know if you've asked yourselves this question:
"How will already demotivated players react when they find their accounts unfairly blocked?
Especially during the summer, when people are already preparing for their holidays and are naturally less willing to spend time in front of a PC or smartphone, preferring outdoor activities instead?"
My prediction is simple: they'll just uninstall the game and move on to something else.


md-quotelink
medal 6680
4 days ago Translate

Maurizio
Another crazy idea. There seems to be no rational plan behind the game's management. Or perhaps there is one, but there's a complete lack of ability to make long-term decisions.
After the last two years of the game, I can honestly say that this is my firm conclusion.
In any case, instead of blaming the person who creates 1,000 accounts, it would have been enough to require each account to be linked to a verified email address and limit each user to a maximum of three accounts.


This is also true! Instead of limiting accounts, it would be enough to link each account to a REAL email address and only allow access to the game once the account has been verified via email.


This would make it impossible to create even 10 email addresses per day, register 10 IGP accounts, and simultaneously verify these 10 accounts via 10 different links.
md-quotelink
medal 5379
4 days ago

Jack
A user based in Spain created 1000 accounts in a single day a few days ago. 100+ accounts a few days later. Accounts were being used to flood and manipulate the transfers market and to ruin the integrity of the game. If you want to blame someone forcing us to place restrictions on the system, then blame them for abusing the freedoms we offered. Action had to be taken to address what was going on, and someone rightly picked up on my quote from another thread above. It has been on our radar for a while, and we've been watching what they are doing.

There will be exceptions where users have more than 3 accounts that may have a legitimate case to maintain them. Ironically, I expect they will vote 3+ times in this poll too, so I wouldn't trust the results.

I will be happy to consult on whether there is anything we can do to help without unlocking the situation I described above again.



Maybe add verified accounts could be a possibility? I mean if you are able to see which account gets used on a specific device it would make sense to keep track of them and connect the accounts to each other and see if there is at least one account above a certain level. If it’s the case you can allow more than 3 accounts.
md-quotelink
CEO & CTO medal 5414
4 days ago
Giuliano
This is also true! Instead of limiting accounts, it would be enough to link each account to a REAL email address and only allow access to the game once the account has been verified via email.


This would make it impossible to create even 10 email addresses per day, register 10 IGP accounts, and simultaneously verify these 10 accounts via 10 different links.

Actually, it's easy to make 1000 emails in a day and verify email with scripting. That is why it's better to link by devices, IPs and other factors, if you truly want to eliminate the practice.
md-quotelink
medal 6680
3 days ago Translate

Jack
Actually, it's easy to make 1000 emails in a day and verify email with scripting. That is why it's better to link by devices, IPs and other factors, if you truly want to eliminate the practice.



But, just to know, in the game's approximately 10 years of existence, how many times has a manager created 1,000 accounts in one day?

 I ask because it seems like a problem that has occurred several times if you decided to implement such an extreme solution (limited accounts per device) that creates discontent among the majority of users.
Creating widespread discontent just because ONE Spaniard thought he was smarter than everyone else and instead ended up banned, seems a bit excessive to me.
"A ban doesn't eliminate bad behavior" okay, but punishing everyone because of one idiot could also be bad behavior.
md-quotelink
medal 5456
3 days ago Translate
Hello Jack! I wrote to support twice to solve   an issue caused by suspension...could you answer to me?
md-quotelink
medal 5283
2 days ago
Jack
How many accounts do some of you have? I am willing to grant exceptions, and perhaps we can remove restrictions entirely for some users who are most impacted by this for a time, but I would want them to work back to choosing their 3 most important accounts ideally, not to maintain dozens.



At least open account for the one running my league:) and even 1 team is too much.
md-quotelink
CEO & CTO medal 5414
8 hours ago
When this is reintroduced it will be done differently, applying more aggressively going forwards and less aggressively going backwards. In other words, people who setup reasonable numbers of accounts before the limit will be allowed to keep them.
md-quotelink
medal 6680
35 minutes ago Translate
Well, this could already be a solution. This way, those who already have more than 3 accounts can't create new ones, and at the same time, managers who have more than 3 active, competitive accounts (non-farming and with a developed HQ) can keep their accounts without feeling like they've wasted years improving them.
md-quotelink
angle-double-left ios-arrow-back 1 2 ios-arrow-forward angle-double-right

You must be logged in to post a reply.