ios-personmd-notifications md-help-circle

Profile

  • Guest
    medal 0
  • Posts: 21
  • Post Likes: 3764

Notifications

  • No Unread Notifications

Suggested
Manual promotion

Manual promotion by the league host.

55.56% (15)
Yes
44.44% (12)
No
angle-double-left ios-arrow-back 1 2 ios-arrow-forward angle-double-right
medal 5518
4 days ago
Turn off completely automatic promotion.  Let the league host promote the members himself.  If the leader of the league is not active, then let him stay in the group for the next season.
md-quotelink
medal 5215
4 days ago

Igor
Turn off completely automatic promotion.  Let the league host promote the members himself.  If the leader of the league is not active, then let him stay in the group for the next season.

this has happened several times in my league, an elite member leaves the league at the end of season , I would like to bring up the 5th pro in the elite league but this is not currently possible, that's why a manual promotion could be a good idea if the élite league is not complete and if the 5th pro accepte it 
md-quotelink
medal 5518
4 days ago

Rémy

Igor
Turn off completely automatic promotion.  Let the league host promote the members himself.  If the leader of the league is not active, then let him stay in the group for the next season.

this has happened several times in my league, an elite member leaves the league at the end of season , I would like to bring up the 5th pro in the elite league but this is not currently possible, that's why a manual promotion could be a good idea if the élite league is not complete and if the 5th pro accepte it 


I think this is easy to do.  Add buttons to the activity menu.  There is a remove from the league, add a promotion, add a downgrade.  Make it a condition to promote or downgrade only between seasons.

md-quotelink
medal 5563
4 days ago
Igor
Turn off completely automatic promotion.  Let the league host promote the members himself.  If the leader of the league is not active, then let him stay in the group for the next season.


Not a bad suggestion but it also opens the door to abuse, toxic hosts demoting players for no reason or only promoting friends.

md-quotelink
medal 5518
4 days ago (Last edited by Igor Barynoff 4 days ago)
Antonio
Igor
Turn off completely automatic promotion.  Let the league host promote the members himself.  If the leader of the league is not active, then let him stay in the group for the next season.


Not a bad suggestion but it also opens the door to abuse, toxic hosts demoting players for no reason or only promoting friends.



I agree.  Such hosts should be punished.  Or find a league with a good host.

Let them play with friends in a closed league.  This game is multiplayer and the host must take their responsibilities seriously.  Do you doubtfully agree?  If there is no trust in the host, then why are you in this league?
md-quotelink
medal 5139 MODERATOR
4 days ago
No need to completely deactivate automatic promotion/relegation. Hosts can do that for their league if they prefer no or manual only tier changes or use the automatic for convenience.

To limit abuse I suggested in an older thread it could require consent by both parties, host and manager, similar to the friends list. 
md-quotelink
medal 5215
4 days ago

Frank
No need to completely deactivate automatic promotion/relegation. Hosts can do that for their league if they prefer no or manual only tier changes or use the automatic for convenience.

To limit abuse I suggested in an older thread it could require consent by both parties, host and manager, similar to the friends list. 



i agree its a good one 
md-quotelink
medal 5518
4 days ago

Frank
No need to completely deactivate automatic promotion/relegation. Hosts can do that for their league if they prefer no or manual only tier changes or use the automatic for convenience.

To limit abuse I suggested in an older thread it could require consent by both parties, host and manager, similar to the friends list. 


[url=][img][/url]

[/img]
md-quotelink
medal 5215
3 days ago

Igor

Frank
No need to completely deactivate automatic promotion/relegation. Hosts can do that for their league if they prefer no or manual only tier changes or use the automatic for convenience.

To limit abuse I suggested in an older thread it could require consent by both parties, host and manager, similar to the friends list. 


[url=][img][/url]

[/quote]
😍


[/img]
md-quotelink
medal 5563
3 days ago
IMHO one only knows a host is toxic from experience, thus when it’s too late.

On forum I regularly find messages about managers getting kicked for no reason, add manual promotion and these messages will multiply.

That’s why I believe the perils of manual promotion outweigh the gains.
md-quotelink
medal 5994
3 days ago
Downvote, A league host could easily send his friend who hasn’t ever played the game and is a level 1 to elite. They could also if they don’t like a manager send them to rookie, this would be insanely abused and broken.
md-quotelink
medal 5032 COMMUNITY MANAGER
3 days ago

Antonio
IMHO one only knows a host is toxic from experience, thus when it’s too late.

On forum I regularly find messages about managers getting kicked for no reason, add manual promotion and these messages will multiply.

That’s why I believe the perils of manual promotion outweigh the gains.



Dillon
Downvote, A league host could easily send his friend who hasn’t ever played the game and is a level 1 to elite. They could also if they don’t like a manager send them to rookie, this would be insanely abused and broken.


That’s what we think at the studio. 👆

md-quotelink
medal 5518
3 days ago

Antonio
IMHO one only knows a host is toxic from experience, thus when it’s too late.

On forum I regularly find messages about managers getting kicked for no reason, add manual promotion and these messages will multiply.

That’s why I believe the perils of manual promotion outweigh the gains.


I'm sorry to hear that. In my league, the members are very good people. We have been communicating for many years, helping newcomers to quickly understand the game. I hear only good reviews about myself as a host.

md-quotelink
medal 5563
3 days ago

Igor

Antonio
IMHO one only knows a host is toxic from experience, thus when it’s too late.

On forum I regularly find messages about managers getting kicked for no reason, add manual promotion and these messages will multiply.

That’s why I believe the perils of manual promotion outweigh the gains.


I'm sorry to hear that. In my league, the members are very good people. We have been communicating for many years, helping newcomers to quickly understand the game. I hear only good reviews about myself as a host.



But not everyone is as lucky to have a good host like you, Igor. Unfortunately

md-quotelink
medal 6169
3 days ago
Tbh i think it would be a good idea. Yes ok it could be abused but so can the kick button!
Maybe to try and get rid of toxic hosts you can make a system that involves other players voting  if they feel its fair for the manual promotion/relegation to happen. (This would need to be a % rather than  set number as all leagues have different amount of players)
md-quotelink
medal 5899
3 days ago

Antonio

Igor

Antonio
IMHO one only knows a host is toxic from experience, thus when it’s too late.

On forum I regularly find messages about managers getting kicked for no reason, add manual promotion and these messages will multiply.

That’s why I believe the perils of manual promotion outweigh the gains.


I'm sorry to hear that. In my league, the members are very good people. We have been communicating for many years, helping newcomers to quickly understand the game. I hear only good reviews about myself as a host.



But not everyone is as lucky to have a good host like you, Igor. Unfortunately




And what prevents others from finding a better host? 
md-quotelink
medal 5563
3 days ago

Sergiy

Antonio

Igor

Antonio
IMHO one only knows a host is toxic from experience, thus when it’s too late.

On forum I regularly find messages about managers getting kicked for no reason, add manual promotion and these messages will multiply.

That’s why I believe the perils of manual promotion outweigh the gains.


I'm sorry to hear that. In my league, the members are very good people. We have been communicating for many years, helping newcomers to quickly understand the game. I hear only good reviews about myself as a host.



But not everyone is as lucky to have a good host like you, Igor. Unfortunately




And what prevents others from finding a better host? 


I don’t know but judging on the forum messages, managers just don’t 

md-quotelink
medal 5899
3 days ago
Antonio

Sergiy

Antonio

Igor

Antonio
IMHO one only knows a host is toxic from experience, thus when it’s too late.

On forum I regularly find messages about managers getting kicked for no reason, add manual promotion and these messages will multiply.

That’s why I believe the perils of manual promotion outweigh the gains.


I'm sorry to hear that. In my league, the members are very good people. We have been communicating for many years, helping newcomers to quickly understand the game. I hear only good reviews about myself as a host.



But not everyone is as lucky to have a good host like you, Igor. Unfortunately




And what prevents others from finding a better host? 


I don’t know but judging on the forum messages, managers just don’t 



So this is not a problem of hosts and leagues, but of the managers themselves? 

md-quotelink
medal 5215
3 days ago

José

Antonio
IMHO one only knows a host is toxic from experience, thus when it’s too late.

On forum I regularly find messages about managers getting kicked for no reason, add manual promotion and these messages will multiply.

That’s why I believe the perils of manual promotion outweigh the gains.



Dillon
Downvote, A league host could easily send his friend who hasn’t ever played the game and is a level 1 to elite. They could also if they don’t like a manager send them to rookie, this would be insanely abused and broken.


That’s what we think at the studio. 👆


this has happened several times in my league, an elite member leaves the league at the end of season , I would like to bring up the 5th pro in the elite league but this is not currently possible, that's why a manual promotion could be a good idea if the élite league is not complete and if the 5th pro accepte it 
 

/ in this case what do you think ?
md-quotelink
medal 5563
3 days ago

Sergiy
Antonio

Sergiy

Antonio

Igor

Antonio
IMHO one only knows a host is toxic from experience, thus when it’s too late.

On forum I regularly find messages about managers getting kicked for no reason, add manual promotion and these messages will multiply.

That’s why I believe the perils of manual promotion outweigh the gains.


I'm sorry to hear that. In my league, the members are very good people. We have been communicating for many years, helping newcomers to quickly understand the game. I hear only good reviews about myself as a host.



But not everyone is as lucky to have a good host like you, Igor. Unfortunately




And what prevents others from finding a better host? 


I don’t know but judging on the forum messages, managers just don’t 



So this is not a problem of hosts and leagues, but of the managers themselves? 



Yes but you can’t make a certain player go somewhere else, they need to do that themselves. All you can do is advertise your league on leagues subforum.

md-quotelink
angle-double-left ios-arrow-back 1 2 ios-arrow-forward angle-double-right

You must be logged in to post a reply.