ℳℛ
I agree with many things that has been said above, but my attitude towards this problem is slightly different.
I understood why hards were severely downgraded as they had been greatly overpowered which resulted in hards only strategy (or start on ss and all other stints on hards) be the only one possible. That looked absolutely silly and made me lose almost all of my motivation to play the game just before the "notorious" tyre updated was released.
Maybe reducing the gap in perfomance and tyre wear between tyre types could have made it better, but I suppose the devs calculated different scenarios and somehow came up with that particular one.
Yes, maybe it is a bit "mainstream", but why not after all? The more players play this game, the better, or I do get it wrong?
I don't know what's happening in other parts of the game community, but the russian speaking one has been slowly dying out, new players just get demotivated as they can't compete with the old dogs.
So that's why I think these "random" events, where players could get a real chance to win or at least get more points than they have used to get, is good, really good if we want the game community to grow.
But on the other hand it would be good for old players to give us some kind of a compensation, where more random events is combined with giving us more means of control over other aspects of gameplay like manual qualification, blue flags or clear understanding of what pitstops depend on (maybe make it depend on certain staff traits).
That's an ideal setup, where everyone would be happy in my point of view.
Manual qualifying round is the key. It would solve all the main and bigger problems, in my opinion. Giving a manager the possibility to create his own destiny but still keeping a few random things in the game. At least, with manual quali round, one gets to know he couldn't have done any better than that and would run the live race with a different mood and another spirit.
Devs should really make it happen, somehow. It would really make the game a better game.
And then, they should also solve other smaller (still big) problems listed above and in other topics around the forums. But manual quali round needs to happen, it really needs. Somehow.