ios-personmd-notifications md-help-circle

Profile

  • Guest
    medal 0
  • Posts: 21
  • Post Likes: 3765

Notifications

  • No Unread Notifications

Suggested
Problem of Reputation System

warning
This thread is closed. Threads older than 6 weeks are closed automatically. To continue this discussion, create a new thread.
angle-double-left ios-arrow-back 1 2 ios-arrow-forward angle-double-right
medal 5002 Super Mod
3 years 273 days ago
OK. Main topic is a suggestion that the Rep calculation is changed to somehow favour managers in your league who finish out of the points 27 seconds behind the leader.

1. It's a horribly over complicated system that just won't work as I explained in post number 4... just before you prompted off-topic discussion by bringing Lolita into the argument, having already told everyone what I would say or do.

2. Even if a system were to be put in place that somehow used overall race time to calculate reputation... finishing 27 seconds behind the winner in a mediocre league would not be fast enough to reward anyone with positive reputation.
md-quotelink
medal 5000
3 years 273 days ago (Last edited by Lai Yong Liang 3 years 273 days ago)
Still think Bastian's suggestion is the best anyway.
Kevin, I think you're just focus on keep repeating that "27 secs behind the winner shouldn't deserve higher reputation" from all your replies. I saw no point on that but I still gave likes to your replies because there's the only thing, or point that you can say I'm wrong.
md-quotelink
medal 5002
3 years 273 days ago (Last edited by Antonio Ascari 3 years 273 days ago)
Lai
Still think Bastian's suggestion is the best anyway.
Kevin, I think you're just focus on keep repeating that "27 secs behind the winner shouldn't deserve higher reputation" from all your replies. I saw no point on that but I still gave likes to your replies because there's the only thing, or point that you can say I'm wrong.


You brought this up, Lai, you ask to be on topic, in your original post you say guys finishing 20 to 40 seconds behind the leader shouldnt lose rep.

I have to agree with Kevin, for one they should lose rep, and two your proposal is way too complicated.

Btw, i’m not saying current system is flawless.
md-quotelink
medal 5000
3 years 273 days ago
Slo
Lai
Still think Bastian's suggestion is the best anyway.
Kevin, I think you're just focus on keep repeating that "27 secs behind the winner shouldn't deserve higher reputation" from all your replies. I saw no point on that but I still gave likes to your replies because there's the only thing, or point that you can say I'm wrong.


You brought this up, Lai, you ask to be on topic, in your original post you say guys finishing 20 to 40 seconds behind the leader shouldnt lose rep



I think only Bastian is actually understand the main & main topic of this thread & only he knows what I was actually thinking before posting the thread. The main topic & thesis statement is located at the last sentence of first paragraph. I was just followed the essay format to write only.
md-quotelink
medal 5002
3 years 273 days ago

Lai
Slo
Lai
Still think Bastian's suggestion is the best anyway.
Kevin, I think you're just focus on keep repeating that "27 secs behind the winner shouldn't deserve higher reputation" from all your replies. I saw no point on that but I still gave likes to your replies because there's the only thing, or point that you can say I'm wrong.


You brought this up, Lai, you ask to be on topic, in your original post you say guys finishing 20 to 40 seconds behind the leader shouldnt lose rep



I think only Bastian is actually understand the main & main topic of this thread & only he knows what I was actually thinking before posting the thread. The main topic & thesis statement is located at the last sentence of first paragraph. I was just followed the essay format to write only.


I cant make out your paragraphs, pls repeat your thesis
md-quotelink
medal 5000
3 years 273 days ago

Slo

Lai
Slo
Lai
Still think Bastian's suggestion is the best anyway.
Kevin, I think you're just focus on keep repeating that "27 secs behind the winner shouldn't deserve higher reputation" from all your replies. I saw no point on that but I still gave likes to your replies because there's the only thing, or point that you can say I'm wrong.


You brought this up, Lai, you ask to be on topic, in your original post you say guys finishing 20 to 40 seconds behind the leader shouldnt lose rep



I think only Bastian is actually understand the main & main topic of this thread & only he knows what I was actually thinking before posting the thread. The main topic & thesis statement is located at the last sentence of first paragraph. I was just followed the essay format to write only.


I cant make out your paragraphs, pls repeat your thesis



Thesis: Moderate managers will dominate the league easily and reputation increased very fast if they went to join a high reputation, but weaker & uncompetitive league. And we need to solve the problem. Bastian has gave a good solution which is, increase the factor of the league reputation. For example if you race in a stronger league a 10th place would give the same Reputation gain like 1st place in a weaker league.
md-quotelink
medal 5002
3 years 273 days ago
Lai

Slo

Lai
Slo
Lai
Still think Bastian's suggestion is the best anyway.
Kevin, I think you're just focus on keep repeating that "27 secs behind the winner shouldn't deserve higher reputation" from all your replies. I saw no point on that but I still gave likes to your replies because there's the only thing, or point that you can say I'm wrong.


You brought this up, Lai, you ask to be on topic, in your original post you say guys finishing 20 to 40 seconds behind the leader shouldnt lose rep



I think only Bastian is actually understand the main & main topic of this thread & only he knows what I was actually thinking before posting the thread. The main topic & thesis statement is located at the last sentence of first paragraph. I was just followed the essay format to write only.


I cant make out your paragraphs, pls repeat your thesis



Thesis: Moderate managers will dominate the league easily and reputation increased very fast if they went to join a high reputation, but weaker & uncompetitive league. And we need to solve the problem. Bastian has gave a good solution which is, increase the factor of the league reputation. For example if you race in a stronger league a 10th place would give the same Reputation gain like 1st place in a weaker league.


I understand the problem but there is no feasable solution as mentionned by Bastian. It is impossible.


1) Your suggested solution means compairing all leagues and by extension compairing all active managers in the game. How do you compare managers, this in itself is very complicated, meaning not impossible but it needs a lot of computing power (server space if you like)

2) This calculation needs to be done not only once, but every race. as different leagues race at different times, thats almost all the time. The computing power this would need is far too big. I’m not an expert on this, if its possible, i’ll accept it can be done. But my gut tels me this would overload any game server out there.



md-quotelink
medal 5000
3 years 273 days ago

Slo
Lai

Slo

Lai
Slo
Lai
Still think Bastian's suggestion is the best anyway.
Kevin, I think you're just focus on keep repeating that "27 secs behind the winner shouldn't deserve higher reputation" from all your replies. I saw no point on that but I still gave likes to your replies because there's the only thing, or point that you can say I'm wrong.


You brought this up, Lai, you ask to be on topic, in your original post you say guys finishing 20 to 40 seconds behind the leader shouldnt lose rep



I think only Bastian is actually understand the main & main topic of this thread & only he knows what I was actually thinking before posting the thread. The main topic & thesis statement is located at the last sentence of first paragraph. I was just followed the essay format to write only.


I cant make out your paragraphs, pls repeat your thesis



Thesis: Moderate managers will dominate the league easily and reputation increased very fast if they went to join a high reputation, but weaker & uncompetitive league. And we need to solve the problem. Bastian has gave a good solution which is, increase the factor of the league reputation. For example if you race in a stronger league a 10th place would give the same Reputation gain like 1st place in a weaker league.


I understand the problem but there is no feasable solution as mentionned by Bastian. It is impossible.


1) Your suggested solution means compairing all leagues and by extension compairing all active managers in the game. How do you compare managers, this in itself is very complicated, meaning not impossible but it needs a lot of computing power (server space if you like)

2) This calculation needs to be done not only once, but every race. as different leagues race at different times, thats almost all the time. The computing power this would need is far too big. I’m not an expert on this, if its possible, i’ll accept it can be done. But my gut tels me this would overload any game server out there.





This needs lots of costs to buy and increase the memory & storage of game server. Maybe in near future, iGP Manager will have the money to do that.

md-quotelink
medal 5002
3 years 273 days ago

Lai

Slo
Lai

Slo

Lai
Slo
Lai
Still think Bastian's suggestion is the best anyway.
Kevin, I think you're just focus on keep repeating that "27 secs behind the winner shouldn't deserve higher reputation" from all your replies. I saw no point on that but I still gave likes to your replies because there's the only thing, or point that you can say I'm wrong.


You brought this up, Lai, you ask to be on topic, in your original post you say guys finishing 20 to 40 seconds behind the leader shouldnt lose rep



I think only Bastian is actually understand the main & main topic of this thread & only he knows what I was actually thinking before posting the thread. The main topic & thesis statement is located at the last sentence of first paragraph. I was just followed the essay format to write only.


I cant make out your paragraphs, pls repeat your thesis



Thesis: Moderate managers will dominate the league easily and reputation increased very fast if they went to join a high reputation, but weaker & uncompetitive league. And we need to solve the problem. Bastian has gave a good solution which is, increase the factor of the league reputation. For example if you race in a stronger league a 10th place would give the same Reputation gain like 1st place in a weaker league.


I understand the problem but there is no feasable solution as mentionned by Bastian. It is impossible.


1) Your suggested solution means compairing all leagues and by extension compairing all active managers in the game. How do you compare managers, this in itself is very complicated, meaning not impossible but it needs a lot of computing power (server space if you like)

2) This calculation needs to be done not only once, but every race. as different leagues race at different times, thats almost all the time. The computing power this would need is far too big. I’m not an expert on this, if its possible, i’ll accept it can be done. But my gut tels me this would overload any game server out there.





This needs lots of costs to buy and increase the memory & storage of game server. Maybe in near future, iGP Manager will have the money to do that.



I propose you buy a lot of tokens so they might have the money to do so
md-quotelink
angle-double-left ios-arrow-back 1 2 ios-arrow-forward angle-double-right

You must be logged in to post a reply.