Sorry for the delay looking in to this, we've been doing a lot of other updates and are working hard on finishing the big updates like the new car and garage. I can tell you we will be turning some of our attention to this next week and testing some solutions.
My preferred route at this point is:
- Reduce the range of wear between tyres
- Scale tyre wear to race duration (so they will wear 4x as fast in a 25% race as a 100% one)
The first change is a relatively minor one, a good suggestion put forward by Dea Male near the start of this topic. Making conservative changes like that with tyres makes more sense, because when people say "there's only one strategy that works", what they usually mean is the tyres are ever so slightly balanced in favour of a certain strategy. Even the people who claim it's "totally" broken are usually only referring to a minor balancing issue, because it only has to be a little bit off balance and it will always go one way. The current tyre balance came in to effect a long time ago because everyone thought Super Softs were too overpowered. We didn't make a huge change, but now the consensus is Hards are overpowered.
The second change is something I've considered doing for a long time, but originally put off for fear it could be confusing to have the tyres behaving inconsistently across the game. However, it would as least allow us to build a consensus on tyres and really balance them in an exciting way without compromise.
The limitation of uniform tyre wear across all race durations is that if we change something to balance a 50% race, it throws 100% off and vice versa, and we can never really achieve consensus. While one league is happy another isn't all the time, and our efforts to balance the tyres are always compromised and complicated by the need to balance them to all race durations. This would be resolved by scaling wear rates to race duration.
So, I think by adjusting wear rates and scaling wear to the race duration we'll be able to create a much more interesting balance. If further tweaks are needed beyond that then they can be implemented as well.